APR 5.99% – 35.99%·$100 – $50,000

Get Advance Loan
Head to head

Personal Loan vs. Rent-to-Own: Which Costs Less for Appliances and Furniture?.

Rent-to-own stores like Rent-A-Center and Aaron's let you take home furniture, appliances, and electronics with no credit check and weekly or monthly payments. The catch: the effective APR on rent-to-own agreements typically runs 100%-300% when calculated over the ownership term. A personal loan - even at 25%-30% for borrowers with poor credit - is almost always cheaper for any item worth owning. The only scenario where rent-to-own makes sense is when you need the item immediately, have no qualifying credit for a personal loan, and genuinely do not intend to buy it outright.

Side by side

Personal Loan vs Rent-to-Own

AttributePersonal LoanRent-to-Own
Credit check requiredYes - varies by lenderNo - rent-to-own accepts all credit
Typical effective APR8%-30% for most borrowers80%-300% implied on total ownership cost
Total cost of a $1,000 item over 18 months~$1,100-$1,250 (at 12%-25%)$1,800-$2,800 (based on weekly payments x term)
OwnershipYou own immediately after purchaseYou rent until final payment; return any time with no further obligation
Early terminationPrepayment penalty possible; usually none on personal loansReturn item any time, no further payments owed
What happens if you miss a paymentLate fee, possible credit score impactCompany retrieves the item; no credit impact (rarely reported to bureaus)
Best forAnyone who qualifies and wants to ownTruly temporary needs or zero-credit borrowers who expect to return the item
Verdicts by scenario

Which wins, when.

  1. 01

    You need appliances long-term (3+ years) and have any credit

    Winner: Personal Loan

    Even at 25% APR, a personal loan on a $1,200 washer costs roughly $350 in interest over 2 years. Rent-to-own for the same washer typically costs $600-$1,000 more than the cash price. The personal loan wins decisively.

  2. 02

    You truly need the item for 3 months then plan to return it

    Winner: Rent-to-Own

    If you rent for $80/month for 3 months and return, you pay $240 for 3 months of use. A personal loan origination would cost more than that in fees alone for a small, short-term use.

  3. 03

    You have no credit and cannot qualify for any personal loan

    Winner: Rent-to-Own

    Before choosing rent-to-own, check: credit union emergency loans (many lend to members with no credit check), CDFI lenders, buy-nothing groups, Facebook Marketplace for cheap used appliances. Rent-to-own is a last resort, not a standard option.

  4. 04

    You need electronics (TV, laptop) short-term

    Winner: Rent-to-Own

    Electronics depreciate rapidly. Rent-to-own on a TV for 4 months then return is arguably rational if the alternative is buying an item you cannot afford to own outright. The math changes if you intend to complete the purchase.

Common questions

Frequently asked.

What is the effective APR on a typical rent-to-own agreement?+

It varies but consistently runs very high. Example: A $700 TV at Rent-A-Center with weekly payments of $25.99 for 78 weeks costs $2,027 total - 190% more than the cash price. The implied APR, calculated as an equivalent loan rate to arrive at that total cost over 78 weeks, exceeds 150%. Even at 30% APR, a personal loan on the same TV would cost $852 total over 18 months - $1,175 less.

Does rent-to-own build credit?+

Almost never. Rent-to-own companies rarely report payments to credit bureaus. Even if you make 78 on-time payments, it typically does not help your credit score. A personal loan or secured credit card is a better credit-building tool.

Is it better to just use a store credit card for appliances?+

Store credit cards (like a Best Buy card) often offer promotional 0% APR for 12-18 months on large appliance purchases. If you can pay the balance off within the promotional period, the effective cost is zero. This beats both rent-to-own and personal loans for shoppers who can budget the payoff. If you cannot pay off within the promotional period, all deferred interest is applied retroactively - which can rival rent-to-own costs.

Other comparisons

Compare real personal-loan offers.

Begin a request